Designing for Accessibility: A Personal Journey
A few years ago, my dad lost a leg to Vascular disease, and then two short years later, he lost the other one. [2] My dad was actually still working right up until the pain in his feet started to get so severe that he could no longer function, and a few months later, one leg was gone below the knee. My parents live in a bungalow (single-level) home, so there weren’t many modifications needed to their home for them to stay in it. There was one exception to this, and that was the bathroom space. [2]
There were several things in their current bathroom that made it very difficult for my dad to use to shower and maneuver. I did not know how to make a bathroom handicap accessible at the time, but I did a bunch of research and came up with some solutions and a design to help my parents out. [2] The whole family chipped in to get this renovation done for my parents. My brother-in-law and my uncle handled the lion’s share of the renovation work, and my sister’s friend who was a plumber gave up a couple of his weekends helping to get the plumbing done for us. My husband and I helped with the work as much as possible, and I also handled all of the design and ordering of materials for my mom. [2]
We got organized, and we got the whole bathroom done in a span of 4 weeks! (This seems absolutely astounding to me at the moment while my current bathroom renovation is entering its 12th week!) My parents have been using the new bathroom now for a few years, and it works perfectly for my Dad. And I think the best part is that you would never know that this was a bathroom that was designed for wheelchair accessibility. I tried to keep function in mind but still make sure it was beautiful for my mom, something I would be proud to have in my own home. [2]
Considering the Guidelines and User Needs
First of all, there are ADA guidelines that talk about the official rules when it comes to things like clearances, space in front of or beside things, doorway widths, and things of that nature. [2] When we were renovating my parent’s bathrooms, we were not able to meet all of the guidelines for accessible bathroom design exactly because we had limited space to work with. However, I had the benefit of being able to ask my dad just what his specific needs were as far as space and easy access. [2]
For example, in the powder room, ADA requirements require a grab bar on the side of the toilet for bathroom safety and easy transfers from the wheelchair to the toilet. However, my dad had already been using the bathroom without one for quite some time and didn’t feel like he needed a bar there, he uses the side of the sink. If he does require it in the future, it’s an easy addition. Also, the powder room is a small bathroom and not large enough according to the guidelines to allow wheelchairs to turn around for it to be a totally compliant bathroom. However, my dad is not a big guy and his wheelchair is pretty small, so it works okay for him. [2]
Designing for Comfort and Accessibility
In order to make the sinks easy for my dad to use from a sitting position, they needed to be a little bit lower and have some open space below to allow him to get closer to them. The vanities that were in my parent’s house before were all extra tall (36″) and had cabinetry on the bottom, so he really had to stretch to reach it. [2] In the ensuite bathroom, we solved this problem by designing some custom cabinetry. I designed a double sink table-style vanity with legs that were a little lower to allow my dad to roll right up to it. I talked to my mom about the storage that she would be losing with this option, and we decided to add a center countertop tower for storage as well as some drawers between the sinks. [2]
In that bathroom, we really only needed one sink to be accessible. However, we felt that having only one would make it look like a handicap-accessible bathroom, and we wanted it to look a little more designerly. So we opted for symmetry, and my parents say they have plenty of storage in this design. [2] We were careful about the bottom clearance as much as the vanity height. We wanted the vanity to be low enough to use, but also enough clearance below that he could roll right under with his chair. That ended up requiring us to source some extra shallow sinks as well. [2] We also used long pulls as towel bars on the front of the vanity rather than placing a hook or a ring on the wall where they would be difficult to reach. [2]
Maximizing Accessibility in the Shower
The shower was by far the trickiest part. [2] We opted to install a curbless shower stall that had a very slight ramp-up from the bathroom floor. This allows it to be a roll-in shower design. In theory, this accessible shower all drains towards the drain, and water shouldn’t end up going on the other side of the ‘slope’ and running into the bathroom. In reality, however, a little bit that splashes here and there was ending up getting out of the shower. [2] In order to deal with this post-construction, we added this plastic shower dam that is like a collapsible water retainer. If you roll your wheelchair over it, it collapses and then just pops back up. It just sticks right down on top of the tile and it works great for keeping the water in. [2]
I asked my dad if he wanted a built-in shower seat, but ultimately, he preferred to use his portable one. He liked to be able to move it around, and it’s not a permanent fixture, so if they ever sell the house and the new people don’t need an accessible design, they don’t need to have a seat. [2] We also designed a niche for storing shampoo and such lower down within easy reach. When laying out the plumbing, we were sure to put the shower controls within reach of someone in a seated position. We also used an adjustable shower head so they can move it up for my mom or down for my Dad, and he can have the water right where he needs it. [2]
Bringing it All Together
Designing these bathrooms specifically for the needs of my Dad and his physical limitations is going to allow my parents to live in this house a lot longer, which is the ultimate goal. [2] My mom also loves the new bathroom designs, the old ones were quite brown and a little dated, and these updates really made a big difference in their home. My mom especially loves that these bathrooms are like… sneakily accessible, they have all the accessible features my dad needs, but yet they don’t look like a hospital bathroom. Good design does not have to be sacrificed for accessibility! [2]
I am so happy that I was able to help out with my parent’s renovations. My Dad was always doing stuff around the house when I was growing up, renovating, building garages and fences, tiling, you name it. I learned most of what I know by helping him, and let’s just say he rubbed off on me. Working alongside my dad is a memory that I will always cherish and I hope to pass along those kinds of memories to my own kids someday. (I am still waiting for that DIY spirit to rub off on one of them… stay tuned!!) [2]
References
[1] Knowledge from https://www.roomsketcher.com/blog/accessible-bathroom-design/
[2] Knowledge from https://erinzubotdesign.com/how-to-make-a-bathroom-handicap-accessible/
[3] Knowledge from https://www.care.com/c/creating-an-accessible-bathroom-for-seniors/
[4] Knowledge from https://liveinplacedesigns.com/guide-to-remodeling-a-handicap-bathroom/
[5] Knowledge from https://bestbath.com/four-tips-designing-accessible-bathroom
[6] Knowledge from http://www.deslaurier.com/en-us/learning-centre/creating-an-accessible-bathroom-design
[7] Knowledge from https://www.tundraland.com/blog/how-to-make-your-bathroom-handicap-accessible/
[8] Knowledge from https://www.springhills.com/resources/accessible-bathroom-designs